Hill and Ponton in plain facts
According to the firm's About page, Hill and Ponton was founded in 1986 in Orlando, Florida. Its FAQ names Brian Hill, an attorney and veteran, and Carol Ponton as the founders. Today it lists offices in Orlando and DeLand, and it serves clients across the United States and its territories, since VA claims are federal and an accredited attorney can represent a veteran in any state.
The firm's tagline is that VA disability is all it does. That focus matters. A general injury or Social Security firm that takes the odd VA appeal will not know the rating schedule, the effective date rules or Board practice as well. The firm also publishes its own totals: 30,000 veterans and $400 million in benefits recovered. Those are self-reported numbers, so treat them as marketing until you see a decision letter in your own file.
How to read Hill and Ponton reviews
Most reviews of any VA law firm are written right after a win or right after a frustration. Neither tells you much about your own odds. Three things are worth pulling out of them.
- Who did the work. Large firms use case managers and intake coordinators. A review that names an attorney who called back tells you more than one that praises the firm in general.
- What kind of case it was. A TDIU grant or a Board win is a hard case. A supplemental claim that only needed one missing record is not. Look for reviews from veterans whose problem looks like yours.
- Time to result. VA sets the pace more than any firm does. A review that complains about a two year wait is often complaining about the Board docket, not the lawyer.
Searches for "Hill and Ponton complaints" bring up the same themes you see for every large VA firm: slow updates, a case declined after an evaluation, and confusion about how the fee was calculated. The firm's own FAQ says it cannot accept every case, which explains some of the declined reviews. The fee confusion is the one you can prevent, by reading the next section before you sign.
What Hill and Ponton charges
The firm states on its FAQ page that it charges nothing upfront, works on contingency, and collects only if it wins and recovers retroactive benefits. If it does not win, you owe nothing. The page does not publish a percentage, so the number you sign is the number that counts.
Federal rules set the frame for every accredited VA attorney, not just this one. Under 38 CFR 14.636, a fee of 20 percent or less of past-due benefits is presumed reasonable, and a fee above 33 1/3 percent is presumed unreasonable. If the agreement says VA should withhold the fee, VA pays the attorney directly from the back pay award and you get the rest. No fee comes out of the monthly payments you receive after the grant.
The key timing rule: no accredited attorney may charge for a claim before VA has issued its first decision on it. So Hill and Ponton, like every VA firm, is a choice you make after a denial, a low rating or a stalled appeal. Our VA disability attorney fee agreement guide explains each clause you will see.
Three worked fee cases at 20 percent
Each case prices the back pay at the December 2025 rates for a veteran with no dependents. The fee is 20 percent of the past-due amount, the common contract figure. Run your own dates in the VA back pay calculator.
| Case | Monthly difference | Back pay | Fee at 20 percent | You keep |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rated 50 percent, raised to 70 percent on higher level review, 14 months | $675.55 | $9,457.70 | $1,891.54 | $7,566.16 |
| PTSD denied, granted at 50 percent at the Board, 24 months | $1,132.90 | $27,189.60 | $5,437.92 | $21,751.68 |
| Rated 70 percent, TDIU granted after appeal, 18 months | $2,130.13 | $38,342.34 | $7,668.47 | $30,673.87 |
The pattern holds for any accredited firm: the fee rises with the length of the wait and the size of the win, and stops on the day of the grant. After that, the TDIU veteran in row three keeps the full $3,938.58 a month for as long as the rating stands. That is why a contingency fee on a real appeal is usually a better deal than a flat or multiple-of-increase fee from an unaccredited consultant. See our Veterans Guardian reviews and fee comparison for that side of the market, priced on the same claims.
Hill and Ponton compared with other options
| Option | Base and history | Fee model | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hill and Ponton | Orlando and DeLand, Florida, VA disability only since 1986 | Contingency on past-due benefits, nothing if no win | Veterans who want a firm that does nothing but VA work |
| Chisholm Chisholm and Kilpatrick | Providence, Rhode Island, veterans law since 1999, over 100 accredited staff and attorneys | Contingency on past-due benefits | Complex Board and Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims cases |
| Local accredited attorney or claims agent | Your state, often a solo or small office | Contingency, sometimes below 20 percent when asked | Veterans who want one named person on the file and a lower fee |
| VSO service officer | County, state or national veterans group | Free | First claims and simple increases |
CCK details come from the CCK About page. Size helps on Board and court work, where volume builds expertise. On a straightforward supplemental claim or higher level review, a smaller accredited office may give you a named attorney and a better rate. Our best VA disability attorneys page lists the points we would compare, and the VA disability appeal attorney page explains which review lane fits which denial.
Questions to ask Hill and Ponton or any VA firm before you sign
- What is the fee percentage, and is it calculated on the whole back pay award or only on the increase you win?
- Will VA withhold the fee from back pay, or will you bill me directly?
- Which attorney is responsible for my file, and who is my day to day contact?
- How often will I get an update, and in what form?
- What happens to the fee if I end the agreement before a decision?
- Do you charge for medical opinions or records separately, and who pays if the case is lost?
Get the answers in writing. If a firm will not put the percentage in the agreement before you sign, keep looking. Confirm any attorney in the VA accreditation search. For a claim where unemployability is the goal, the TDIU lawyer page shows what that appeal is worth.
Hill and Ponton FAQ
Is Hill and Ponton a good law firm?
Hill and Ponton is an established firm that has handled only VA disability cases since 1986, from offices in Orlando and DeLand, Florida, and it takes clients nationwide. Whether it is right for you depends on your claim stage, the fee percentage in the agreement and who will actually work your file.
How much does Hill and Ponton charge?
The firm works on contingency and says it collects only if it wins and recovers retroactive benefits. Federal rules let accredited VA attorneys take a share of past-due benefits, and 20 percent or less is presumed reasonable. Ask for the exact percentage in writing before you sign.
Can Hill and Ponton help with my first VA claim?
No accredited attorney may charge for a claim before VA issues its first decision, so firms like Hill and Ponton step in after a denial or a rating you disagree with. For the first filing, a free Veterans Service Organization is the right helper.
What are common complaints about VA disability law firms?
Across large VA firms the usual complaints are slow replies, talking to coordinators instead of attorneys, cases declined after an evaluation, and surprise at how the fee is calculated. Ask who your contact will be, how often you get updates and how the fee is figured before you sign.
Can I switch from Hill and Ponton to another VA lawyer?
Yes. You revoke the old appointment by filing a new VA Form 21-22a with the new representative. The former firm may claim part of the fee for work already done, so read the termination clause in your agreement and ask the new attorney how the fee will be split.